Swinging Emergers?

Moderators: William Anderson, letumgo

User avatar
Randyflycaster
Posts: 27
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2013 9:36 am
Location: Missoula, Montana
Contact:

Swinging Emergers?

Post by Randyflycaster » Mon Oct 06, 2014 10:10 am

Just curious: Do any of you folks swing emergers? If so, do you use the same techniques as when you swing
soft-hackle flies?

Thanks,
Randy
User avatar
Donald Nicolson
Posts: 290
Joined: Wed May 02, 2012 2:37 pm
Location: Fife,Scotland

Re: Swinging Emergers?

Post by Donald Nicolson » Mon Oct 06, 2014 10:56 am

I'm a little confused. This may be confusion by a common language.
By swinging, do you mean fishing across and then down stream? :?: :?:
Donald Nicolson alias DNicolson

http://donaldnicolson.webplus.net/
User avatar
Old Hat
Posts: 4204
Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2009 12:24 am
Location: Where Deet is a Cologne
Contact:

Re: Swinging Emergers?

Post by Old Hat » Mon Oct 06, 2014 11:03 am

Hi Randy,
"Emergers" is a pretty broad class of flies. What type of emergers were you thinking of?

I think of flymphs, a lot of spiders and other soft hackles as emergers and fish them as such. Every so often I will fish them as nymphs but for the most part as emergers. There are two flies that I will swing that one might not think of and those are the Quigley Cripple style and Elk hair Caddis. I will swing so that they skip or "flutter" about on the surface of the water. The Quigley Cripple works very good for this.

Donald, for the most part, swinging here is a simple cast made quartered down and across then swung like a pendulum on a tight line to the near bank. It is often coupled with an initial dead drift to set the depth.

Carl
I hate it when I think I'm buying organic vegetables, and when I get home I discover they are just regular donuts.
http://www.oldhatflytying.com
User avatar
Randyflycaster
Posts: 27
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2013 9:36 am
Location: Missoula, Montana
Contact:

Re: Swinging Emergers?

Post by Randyflycaster » Mon Oct 06, 2014 11:59 am

By emergers I mean traditional, non-soft-hackle, emergers, e.g. CDC emergers.

By swinging I mean casting upstream or three-quarters downstream, as Old Hat described.

Randy
User avatar
tie2fish
Posts: 5072
Joined: Sun Feb 22, 2009 9:11 am
Location: Harford County, MD

Re: Swinging Emergers?

Post by tie2fish » Mon Oct 06, 2014 1:03 pm

Interesting ... I've never thought of CDC anything as being "traditional", but since "emergers" as a pattern genre are relatively recent, I suppose the use of CDC on them could be considered traditional. In any case, since emergers are supposed to represent either newly hatched insects and/or those in the process of hatching, they ought to behave as such and move at the mercy of the currents. A well-mended swing can certainly mimic that condition.
Some of the same morons who throw their trash around in National parks also vote. That alone would explain the state of American politics. ~ John Gierach, "Still Life with Brook Trout"
User avatar
Ruard
Posts: 1904
Joined: Sun Feb 22, 2009 5:00 am
Location: Alkmaar
Contact:

Re: Swinging Emergers?

Post by Ruard » Mon Oct 06, 2014 3:31 pm

tie2fish wrote:Interesting ... I've never thought of CDC anything as being "traditional", but since "emergers" as a pattern genre are relatively recent, I suppose the use of CDC on them could be considered traditional. In any case, since emergers are supposed to represent either newly hatched insects and/or those in the process of hatching, they ought to behave as such and move at the mercy of the currents. A well-mended swing can certainly mimic that condition.
Leon Links has written a book on CDC and he writes about Marc Petitjean who has done research about the origin of the use of CDC for Fly tying:
the first use as such must be around 1920 by Charles Bickel and Maximilien Joset, who lived in the Swiss Jura. So they are not as traditional as spiders but pretty traditinal I think.

Here in the Netherlands we had not heard of CDC untill 1980.

Greeting


Ruard
There will allways be a solution.
http://www.aflyinholland.nl
User avatar
Old Hat
Posts: 4204
Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2009 12:24 am
Location: Where Deet is a Cologne
Contact:

Re: Swinging Emergers?

Post by Old Hat » Mon Oct 06, 2014 4:19 pm

In that case, I haven't. Not that it wouldn't catch a few fish, I just think there are probably better patterns suited for emerging insects in the swing. I would think the emergers you are describing would not be as lively as I would like.
I hate it when I think I'm buying organic vegetables, and when I get home I discover they are just regular donuts.
http://www.oldhatflytying.com
Mataura mayfly
Posts: 3648
Joined: Thu Oct 27, 2011 6:28 am
Location: Southland, South Island, New Zealand.

Re: Swinging Emergers?

Post by Mataura mayfly » Mon Oct 06, 2014 5:09 pm

Randy, try it- if it works- use it. ;)
There is no "correct' answer and sometimes it take a bit of out of the square thinking to trigger new responses. OK, maybe if you were fishing with Marjan Fratnik you might want to try for a different presentation, but in my small way of thinking- there is no reason you could not drift your emerger cast upstream , until the line draws near right angle to you, give the line a sharp small strip to jerk the fly under the surface and swing it downstream as a cripple Dun or drowned emerger.
If tied as a true emerger on a light wire hook, odds are it is not going to sink very deep and may not give you a nice "Leisenring lift" at the end of the swing that a more true flymph might- but the flymph might not do as well presented upstream either.
There are patterns and styles of fly that (in my opinion) might do what you are asking better- but there is nothing to say an across & down presented cdc emerger will not take fish.

Personally I often drift and swing (as described above) two dry fly patterns here with some success. The Cochybondhu and the Greenwell's Glory.
"Listen to the sound of the river and you will get a trout".... Irish proverb.
User avatar
William Anderson
Site Admin
Posts: 4569
Joined: Mon Feb 23, 2009 3:14 pm
Location: Ashburn, VA 20148
Contact:

Re: Swinging Emergers?

Post by William Anderson » Mon Oct 06, 2014 7:36 pm

Hey Randy. I'm assuming the type of emergers you're referring to are best suited to sight casting to rising fish or to some rise form indicative of emergers in the area. A downstream swing seems like an inappropriate presentation for that type of fly. Flies that become mobile/active during a longer drift may actually emerge if presented well, swung if you like that method. I'm biased to soft hackles for that purpose. Most emergers I've seen on all the other sites and mags and shops etc seem to be designed to be drifted under a dry or indicator. It seems more disruptive than productive to swing this combo in my mind.

That being said, the right fish at the right time may surprise you. A gorgeous brown I took earlier this summer hit a cdc and elk that turned soggy. I did intentionally swing that fly into the prime holding position and it got hammered. All the entomology speculation would carry on about ovipositing caddis or rising caddis. Could be, but I think the food source arrived in the right place at the right time in the right way.

Please, please swing some emergers and report back. Any information can only help. Presentation can get muddy, so I like to see pat answers overturned. =)

Nice question.
"A man should not try to eliminate his complexes, but rather come into accord with them. They are ultimately what directs his conduct in the world." Sigmund Freud.
www.WilliamsFavorite.com
User avatar
Donald Nicolson
Posts: 290
Joined: Wed May 02, 2012 2:37 pm
Location: Fife,Scotland

Re: Swinging Emergers?

Post by Donald Nicolson » Tue Oct 07, 2014 5:36 am

I thought that you might find this article from my web-site might be of interest -
http://donaldnicolson.webplus.net/page15.html

Lawrie called them 'hatching duns', or in modern parlance - emergers. He usually fished them
as the front fly on a pair, with the tail a nymph or spider. But also with the 'hatching dun' as tail.
His book "The Rough Stream Nymph" was originally finished in 1939, but Adolph Hitler's
intervention, delayed publication until 1947. His nymphs were all Skews style and the
spiders Border or North country style.[/ size]
.
Donald Nicolson alias DNicolson

http://donaldnicolson.webplus.net/
Post Reply