Hare's Ear and Plover

[Theroe]

narco / tie2fish

is this a good quality GP skin for me to buy? I realize you cant tell much from a photo, but is this sorta what they SHOULD look like???

Dana

[tie2fish]

It's a little hard to tell, Dana, if the neck area is just ruffled up a bit or whether some of the choice feathers from this area (my favorite spot on the skin) have been plucked. But even if some are missing, there are a lot left and they look to be in good shape. It's been several years since I scored my last plover skin, but given the current scarcity I'd say there are maybe $60.00 worth left for someone not pressed for cash. Plover skins from Cookshill, when available, are currently priced at 40 British pounds, which translate to roughly $53 today.

[upstatetrout]

If you check closed auctions by this seller you will see that this is a stock picture and not the skin you will receive.Also that skins go in the 70 ++ dollar range. His feedback is very good.I took a chance on his last auction and won at 73 dollars.I am awaiting delivery now.Did receive an excellent snipe and magpie skin from Cookshills.Very nice quality and not a lot of money.Also got a beautiful set of waterhen wings
and partridge skin from another UK E bay seller Excellent quality and again not a lot of money.

Tom

[Theroe]

Thank you for the input gentlemen-it will certainly help me make a good decision.

Theroe

[Old Hat]

Great tie Bill. I think I prefer this version to the first one.

I do have a question though that is attached with a little debate.

When did "palmer through thorax" become "Fymph Style" I am not sure that is a completely accurate distinction.

Based on duffer's description we could just as easily say " in John Robert's Style", but that would probably not be an accurate distinction as well.

[tie2fish]

When did "palmer through thorax" become "Flymph Style" I am not sure that is a completely accurate distinction.

To me "flymph style" means that the hackle feather was tied in by the stem before the rest of the fly was constructed. After the thorax was added, the hackle feather was wrapped "backwards" through the thorax where it was caught with the tying thread. The tying thread was then brought forward through the hackle in two wraps before forming a head and being tied off in front of the hackle.

I do understand that this sequence is not unique to what I believe Pete Hidy often used and apologize for implying that. Any future recipes posted by me will use generic terminology only.

[daringduffer]

Here we have a Hare Lug and Plover tied by Roy Christie according to the site where I found it. http://www.swedneckflyfishing.com/classicwet2007.htm



As with other flies, there are a lot of interpretations.

dd

[Old Hat]

Bill, part generalities and part my misinterpretation. I assumed initially that you were referring to the appearance of the open palmer employed not the method in your recipe. Thank you for clarifying.

[daringduffer]

Davie McP. version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6zR2QXREz70

dd